I’m Freaking Out About These 10 Clean Beauty Makeup Finds For Women Over 40

Clean Beauty Makeup Finds With Melissa Meyers

I’m someone who is always on the hunt for the best in clean beauty. I’m constantly testing and trying new products. What I look for are products that really deliver for women over 40 (I am 57). I’m looking for clean beauty makeup finds that are hydrating, enhance my best features, and leave me feeling naturally refreshed and glowing. When I find my absolute favorites that live up to the hype, I give them my “Glow Girl stamp of approval”. These are products that I use time and again, and truly trust.

Mellissa Meyers, the glow girl

Clean Beauty Makeup Finds With Melissa Meyersclean beauty for women over 40

westman atelier clean beauty highlight

10 Best Clean Beauty Makeup Finds by Melissa Meyers

Read on to see the top 10 clean beauty finds in my makeup bag and why they make it easy for me to look my best. I know you will love them as much as I do!

Melissa Meyers, The Glow Girl

Be sure to check out Melissa’s blog, The Glow Girl and her Instagram for more fabulous style and beauty tips!
And, in case you missed it, she also shared this chic, NYC go-to outfit for fall.

Be sure to sign up for the Busbee Style weekly newsletter here. You’ll gain access to exclusive content, shopping suggestions, and helpful style resources for women 40+!


One Palette Wonder

Created by all-round beauty and wellness guru Marcia Kilgore, BEAUTY PIE is a luxury makeup (and skincare) connoisseur’s dream at a fraction of the price. Their Face Palette is an all-in-one blush, bronzer, highlighter, and eyeshadow palette. I love the six matte and shimmer warm-toned, natural shades that give me just the right amount of soft glow. I think as we age, less is more, and this is the perfect natural palette to have on hand. Plus, it’s perfect for travel.

Holy Grail Mascara

As we age, our eyes can get dry and tear up quite a bit! This is why I love Ere Perez’s waterproof mascara! It’s the only clean formula that is especially great for those with sensitive skin. I love the easy-to-apply applicator and it adds the perfect amount of volume and length to my lashes without ever causing any clumping. This mascara stays without smudging even during workouts, swimming and long days!

Perfect Multitasker!

This multi-tasking multi-stick from the wildly popular brand ILIA is one I seem to reach for repeatedly (I love a double-duty product). My favorite shade, “Tenderly”, builds to give color to cheeks or lips for a fresh-faced look. The tones in my face can sometimes look a bit sallow these days so I love to apply on the apples of the cheeks and blend.

Bobbi Brown's Finest

Founded by Bobbi Brown, Jones Road has great clean products that support a natural, no-makeup makeup look for all ages, skin types, and skin tones. This face pencil is the perfect middle ground between a concealer and a foundation. As we age, sunspots and undereye circles seem to appear quite often and this magic pencil fully covers any unwanted redness, dark spots and darkness under my eyes.

Eyeliner for Aging Eyes

Using too much dark eyeliner can age the eyes so I like to line outside of my bottom and top lash line with a bronze shade. Wearing bronze eyeliner is softer than brown or black and is very flattering on all eye colors. This one by Julep comes in the perfect shade and has a great texture. I love the smooth, glide-on application of this gel-like eye pencil. Plus, it never smudges and lasts all day long.

Pop Of Color

This awesome new powder blush is from RMS, one of the pioneers in clean makeup! The super-hydrating formula leaves skin with a silky-smooth finish and is the perfect blush for dry skin. It manages to be both light and buildable while still giving the great pop of color you would expect from a powder blush. This is one of their newest products in the line and one of my favorite finds.

Mature Skin MUST

There is a reason this tinted moisturizer by Saie won several beauty awards. It’s a moisturizer, makeup, and sunscreen all in one that’s formulated with Hyaluronic Acid for deep hydration. I’m obsessed with its skin-smoothing power and love the light coverage for a flawless, glowing finish. This incredible product protects my skin from the sun's damaging rays, noticeably improves the overall texture of my skin, and always leaves it looking dewy and fresh. I think anyone over 40 should have this one in their makeup arsenal.

Beautiful Brows

Our brows tend to thin out as we get older—I remember my mom always telling me as a teenager not to over-tweeze because hers never grew back! Thicker brows change the entire look of your face as they frame the eyes nicely and seem to turn back the clock a few years, too.

Hydrating Lip Oil

My lips are dry and have more fine lines these days so this high-shine, silky lip oil by Saint Jane always hits the mark. My favorite tint is “Cloud” and it’s the perfect sheer shade of soft pink which looks great on all skin tones. This ultra-silky gloss and oil hybrid is infused with antioxidant-rich nutrients, Vitamin C, calming florals, and CBD. I absolutely love the feel and texture of this long-lasting lip oil so if petal pink is not your thing, they come in several great shades, too!

Award Winning

This award-winning, treatment-packed cream highlighter is perfect for cheeks, lips, and eyelids. I love dabbing it on to accentuate my cheekbones, over my brow bone and even my eyelids when not wearing shadow during the day. Best of all—its luxurious formula blends beautifully and leaves my skin with its best glow! Founder and celebrity make-up artist Gucci Westman calls it the ‘closer’ because it gives the most refined polish to the skin.
Join the Conversation

4 thoughts on “I’m Freaking Out About These 10 Clean Beauty Makeup Finds For Women Over 40

  1. I absolutely LOVE the pearl / charm pendant necklace she is wearing in the first picture. Would you mind sharing where I can find it?
    Thank you so much!!

Explore More

explore more
View All Posts

Start Your Style Journey…Join My Style Made Simple Course!

Did you hear?? My Style Made Simple course is LIVE!! Learn more and find out…
Read Post

Look Younger AND Slimmer with These 5 Key Style Tips for Women Over 40

Wondering how to look younger? Find 5 simple style tips for women over 40 that…
Read Post

A Chic Busy Mom Outfit You Can Wear On Repeat This Fall

Sharing ideas for busy mom outfits to make it easy to get dressed every day…
Read + Shop